Newly revealed documents from the ongoing legal battle involving Blake Lively and It Ends With Us director Justin Baldoni suggest a tense confrontation unfolded earlier in 2025 at the New York penthouse Lively shares with her husband, Ryan Reynolds. According to the unsealed exhibits, Reynolds allegedly confronted Baldoni over comments perceived as inappropriate and body-related, an interaction that reportedly took place in the presence of Taylor Swift and Hugh Jackman.
The account, first referenced in an email sent to Baldoni’s publicist, claims Reynolds forcefully expressed that Baldoni’s questions regarding Blake’s body and weight were unacceptable. The documents outline that both Blake and Ryan accused Baldoni of making remarks they considered fat-shaming, leaving him shaken and apologetic during the discussion. The report further suggests Baldoni was emotional and repeatedly expressed remorse following the confrontation.
Taylor Swift and Hugh Jackman were reportedly in the apartment during the exchange and had previously been listed as potential witnesses by Blake’s legal team. Their presence could become significant as the case progresses, though representatives for both have declined to comment publicly.
This timeline is consistent with earlier accounts stating that Taylor visited Blake’s apartment after being invited, reportedly unaware that Baldoni would also be present. Sources noted that while Swift did not participate in the confrontation, she expressed excitement about the film It Ends With Us.
Blake Lively filed her lawsuit in December 2024, accusing Baldoni and others involved with the film of workplace misconduct, harassment, and retaliation—allegations that Justin Baldoni’s team has denied. Attempts were made in 2025 to subpoena Taylor Swift, indicating her potential relevance as a witness. The case is expected to go to trial in March 2026, with additional filings anticipated as both sides finalize their evidence and witness lists.